The 10 top-rated water heater plumbers in Columbus, OH
We checked 12 companies against Google reviews, years in business, and published warranties, then scored each one out of 100. Payment never changes a rank.
Updated Method v2.1Researched by Strive LeadGenFranklin County
- Every license checked on the state record
- Every rating dated and sourced
- No company pays to be listed or ranked
- Score breakdown shown for every company
Free quote in Columbus
Get a free water heater quote from a licensed Columbus plumber
Got it. We will be in touch within 1 business day.
We will tell you the name of the plumber we would connect you with. Your details go to them only if you say yes. If you change your mind, reply STOP or email [email protected].
- We name the plumber before sharing anything
- Your details go to one company, never a list
- Free, no obligation. Stop texts anytime
Ohio, Illinois and Texas. For a leak or a gas smell, do not wait for us: shut off the water or leave the house and call your gas utility or 911.
Short answer
Columbus gets its water from Columbus Water & Power (formerly Columbus Department of Public Utilities, Division of Water). Replacing a water heater needs a permit from City of Columbus Building and Zoning Services (BZS), 111 N Front St, 614-645-7433. Below are the 10 top-rated plumbers serving Columbus on our method, built Oct 14, 2026.
Looking for the best water heater plumber in Columbus? Here is how 10 companies score
Score out of 100. Google rating with review count.
| # | Company | Best for | Warranty | Score | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |  Eco Plumbers, Electricians, and HVAC Technicians | Best overall | 4.9(20,873) | Terms on its site | 87.1 |
| 2 |  Emergency Plumbing Heating & Air | Longest track record | 4.8(1,207) | None found | 86.5 |
| 3 |  Amanda Plumbing Sewer & Drain | 4.8(1,220) | None found | 81.1 | |
| 4 |  Water Heaters Plus! Inc. | 4.9(584) | None found | 77.5 | |
| 5 | The Waterworks | 4.7(2,255) | None found | 76.0 | |
| 6 |  Mr. FixAll Plumbing and Drainage Services, LLC | 4.9(527) | None found | 69.5 | |
| 7 |  Apex Pros Plumbing, Electrical, Heating and Air | 4.7(7,058) | None found | 68.4 | |
| 8 |  Wind Bender Heating Cooling Plumbing LLC | 4.7(985) | None found | 66.2 | |
| 9 | Allegiant Plumbing | 4.8(130) | None found | 65.2 | |
| 10 | Shorty's Plumbing LLC | 4.9(114) | Terms on its site | 63.4 |
How we make money: when you request a quote, we work to match you with one licensed plumber who pays us for the referral. We tell you who first, nothing is shared unless you say yes, and if we cannot match you we tell you that too. No company pays to be on this list, and payment never changes a rank.How we rank
The full reviews
What stands out and what to know come only from the records we checked.
- #1
Best overall
Eco Plumbers, Electricians, and HVAC Technicians
4.9 from 20,873 Google reviews · Based in Hilliard
What stands out
- Most Google reviews on this list (20,873)
- Lists warranty or guarantee terms on its website
Worth knowing
- Nothing flagged in the records we checked; still ask any plumber for a written quote
- License
- Ohio OCILB Plumbing Contractor PL.23868, confirmed on the public lookup
- Founded
- 2007
- Insurance on file
- Ask for a certificate
- Warranty
- One-year warranty on all service and new equipment unless the invoice says otherwise; 'No Lemons' guarantee replaces failed newly installed components
Visit website of Eco Plumbers, Electricians, and HVAC TechniciansThis button does not contact Eco Plumbers, Electricians, and HVAC Technicians. We match you with one licensed plumber and tell you who before sharing anything.
Full score breakdown and sources
Strongest factors: a Google rating of 4.9 from 20,873 reviews and a stated founding year of 2007.
- Google Google rating 4.9 from 20,873 reviews (as of Oct 6, 2026) Source
- Founded BBB profile lists the business as started in 2007 Source
- License Ohio OCILB Plumbing Contractor PL.23868, confirmed on the public lookup Source
- Insurance No public insurance record checked; ask for a certificate.
- Warranty One-year warranty on all service and new equipment unless the invoice says otherwise; 'No Lemons' guarantee replaces failed newly installed components
- Coverage Data coverage: 75 of 75 measurable points
- geteco.com/
- google.com/maps/search/Eco+Plumbers+4691+Northwest+Pkwy+Hilliard+OH
- elicense4.com.ohio.gov/Lookup/LicenseLookup.aspx
- bbb.org/us/oh/hilliard/profile/plumber/eco-plumbers-electricians-and-h
- geteco.com/happiness-guarantees/
Checked Oct 6, 2026.
- #2
Longest track record
Emergency Plumbing Heating & Air
4.8 from 1,207 Google reviews · Based in Delaware
What stands out
- 4.8 Google rating from 1,207 reviews
- In business since 1977
Worth knowing
- No warranty terms found on its website
- License
- Ohio OCILB Plumbing Contractor PL.32020, confirmed on the public lookup
- Founded
- 1977
- Insurance on file
- Ask for a certificate
- Warranty
- None found in writing
Visit website of Emergency Plumbing Heating & AirThis button does not contact Emergency Plumbing Heating & Air. We match you with one licensed plumber and tell you who before sharing anything.
Full score breakdown and sources
Strongest factors: a Google rating of 4.8 from 1,207 reviews and 49 years in business.
- Google Google rating 4.8 from 1,207 reviews (as of Oct 6, 2026) Source
- Founded Operating since 1977 Source
- License Ohio OCILB Plumbing Contractor PL.32020, confirmed on the public lookup Source
- Insurance No public insurance record checked; ask for a certificate.
- Coverage Data coverage: 75 of 75 measurable points
- emergencyplumbingservice.com/
- google.com/maps/search/Emergency+Plumbing+Heating+%26+Air+3354+US+High
- elicense4.com.ohio.gov/Lookup/LicenseLookup.aspx
- bbb.org/us/oh/delaware/profile/plumber/emergency-plumbing-heating-air-
Checked Oct 6, 2026.
- #3
Amanda Plumbing Sewer & Drain
4.8 from 1,220 Google reviews · Based in Delaware
What stands out
- 4.8 Google rating from 1,220 reviews
- In business since 1995
Worth knowing
- No warranty terms found on its website
- License
- Ohio OCILB Plumbing Contractor PL.49045, confirmed on the public lookup
- Founded
- 1995
- Insurance on file
- Ask for a certificate
- Warranty
- None found in writing
Visit website of Amanda Plumbing Sewer & DrainThis button does not contact Amanda Plumbing Sewer & Drain. We match you with one licensed plumber and tell you who before sharing anything.
Full score breakdown and sources
Strongest factors: a Google rating of 4.8 from 1,220 reviews and 31 years in business.
- Google Google rating 4.8 from 1,220 reviews (as of Oct 6, 2026) Source
- Founded Operating since 1995 Source
- License Ohio OCILB Plumbing Contractor PL.49045, confirmed on the public lookup Source
- Insurance No public insurance record checked; ask for a certificate.
- Coverage Data coverage: 75 of 75 measurable points
- amandaplumbing.com/
- google.com/maps/search/Amanda+Plumbing+4425+Columbus+Pike+Delaware+OH
- elicense4.com.ohio.gov/Lookup/LicenseLookup.aspx
- bbb.org/us/oh/delaware/profile/plumber/amanda-plumbing-0302-12006448
Checked Oct 6, 2026.
- #4
Water Heaters Plus! Inc.
4.9 from 584 Google reviews · Based in Worthington
What stands out
- 4.9 Google rating from 584 reviews
- Says it was founded in 2003
Worth knowing
- No warranty terms found on its website
- License
- Ohio OCILB Plumbing Contractor PL.27744, confirmed on the public lookup
- Founded
- 2003 (company says)
- Insurance on file
- Ask for a certificate
- Warranty
- None found in writing
Visit website of Water Heaters Plus! Inc.This button does not contact Water Heaters Plus! Inc.. We match you with one licensed plumber and tell you who before sharing anything.
Full score breakdown and sources
Strongest factors: a Google rating of 4.9 from 584 reviews and a stated founding year of 2003.
- Google Google rating 4.9 from 584 reviews (as of Oct 6, 2026) Source
- Founded Company states it was founded in 2003. Credit capped at 20 years until a second source confirms it Source
- License Ohio OCILB Plumbing Contractor PL.27744, confirmed on the public lookup Source
- Insurance No public insurance record checked; ask for a certificate.
- Coverage Data coverage: 75 of 75 measurable points
- waterheatersplus.com/
- google.com/maps/search/Water+Heaters+Plus+6330+Proprietors+Rd+Worthing
- elicense4.com.ohio.gov/Lookup/LicenseLookup.aspx
- waterheatersplus.com/reviews/service-area
Checked Oct 6, 2026.
- #5
The Waterworks
4.7 from 2,255 Google reviews · Based in Columbus
What stands out
- 2,255 Google reviews
- Says it was founded in 1986
Worth knowing
- No warranty terms found on its website
- 4.7 rating trails most companies on this list
- License
- Ohio OCILB Plumbing Contractor PL.12795, confirmed on the public lookup
- Founded
- 1986 (company says)
- Insurance on file
- Ask for a certificate
- Warranty
- None found in writing
Visit website of The WaterworksThis button does not contact The Waterworks. We match you with one licensed plumber and tell you who before sharing anything.
Full score breakdown and sources
Strongest factors: a Google rating of 4.7 from 2,255 reviews and a stated founding year of 1986.
- Google Google rating 4.7 from 2,255 reviews (as of Oct 6, 2026) Source
- Founded Company states it was founded in 1986. Credit capped at 20 years until a second source confirms it Source
- License Ohio OCILB Plumbing Contractor PL.12795, confirmed on the public lookup Source
- Insurance No public insurance record checked; ask for a certificate.
- Coverage Data coverage: 75 of 75 measurable points
- thewaterworks.com/
- google.com/maps/search/The+Waterworks+550+Schrock+Rd+Columbus+OH
- elicense4.com.ohio.gov/Lookup/LicenseLookup.aspx
- thewaterworks.com/about-us/
Checked Oct 6, 2026.
- #6
Mr. FixAll Plumbing and Drainage Services, LLC
4.9 from 527 Google reviews · Based in Marion
What stands out
- 4.9 Google rating from 527 reviews
Worth knowing
- No warranty terms found on its website
- 6 years in business
- License
- Ohio OCILB Plumbing Contractor PL.49048, confirmed on the public lookup
- Founded
- 2020
- Insurance on file
- Ask for a certificate
- Warranty
- None found in writing
Visit website of Mr. FixAll Plumbing and Drainage Services, LLCThis button does not contact Mr. FixAll Plumbing and Drainage Services, LLC. We match you with one licensed plumber and tell you who before sharing anything.
Full score breakdown and sources
Strongest factors: a Google rating of 4.9 from 527 reviews and a stated founding year of 2020.
- Google Google rating 4.9 from 527 reviews (as of Oct 6, 2026) Source
- Founded Company states it was founded in 2020 Source
- License Ohio OCILB Plumbing Contractor PL.49048, confirmed on the public lookup Source
- Insurance No public insurance record checked; ask for a certificate.
- Coverage Data coverage: 75 of 75 measurable points
- fixalloh.com/
- google.com/maps/search/Mr.+FixAll+Plumbing+2034+Harding+Hwy+E+Marion+O
- elicense4.com.ohio.gov/Lookup/LicenseLookup.aspx
Checked Oct 6, 2026.
- #7
Apex Pros Plumbing, Electrical, Heating and Air
4.7 from 7,058 Google reviews · Based in Columbus
What stands out
- 7,058 Google reviews
Worth knowing
- No warranty terms found on its website
- 4.7 rating trails most companies on this list
- License
- Ohio OCILB Plumbing Contractor PL.46793, confirmed on the public lookup
- Founded
- 2021
- Insurance on file
- Ask for a certificate
- Warranty
- None found in writing
Visit website of Apex Pros Plumbing, Electrical, Heating and AirThis button does not contact Apex Pros Plumbing, Electrical, Heating and Air. We match you with one licensed plumber and tell you who before sharing anything.
Full score breakdown and sources
Strongest factors: a Google rating of 4.7 from 7,058 reviews and 5 years in business.
- Google Google rating 4.7 from 7,058 reviews (as of Oct 6, 2026) Source
- Founded Operating since 2021 Source
- License Ohio OCILB Plumbing Contractor PL.46793, confirmed on the public lookup Source
- Insurance No public insurance record checked; ask for a certificate.
- Coverage Data coverage: 75 of 75 measurable points
- apexpros.com/
- google.com/maps/search/Apex+Pros+6663+Huntley+Rd+Columbus+OH
- elicense4.com.ohio.gov/Lookup/LicenseLookup.aspx
- apexpros.com/about/
Checked Oct 6, 2026.
- #8
Wind Bender Heating Cooling Plumbing LLC
4.7 from 985 Google reviews · Based in Fairborn
What stands out
- In business since 2005
Worth knowing
- No warranty terms found on its website
- 4.7 rating trails most companies on this list
- License
- Ohio OCILB Plumbing Contractor (state roster; Ohio residential plumbing licensing is otherwise local) PL.38289, confirmed on the public lookup
- Founded
- 2005
- Insurance on file
- Ask for a certificate
- Warranty
- None found in writing
Visit website of Wind Bender Heating Cooling Plumbing LLCThis button does not contact Wind Bender Heating Cooling Plumbing LLC. We match you with one licensed plumber and tell you who before sharing anything.
Full score breakdown and sources
Strongest factors: a Google rating of 4.7 from 985 reviews and 21 years in business.
- Google Google rating 4.7 from 985 reviews (as of Oct 6, 2026) Source
- Founded Operating since 2005 Source
- License Ohio OCILB Plumbing Contractor (state roster; Ohio residential plumbing licensing is otherwise local) PL.38289, confirmed on the public lookup Source
- Insurance No public insurance record checked; ask for a certificate.
- Coverage Data coverage: 75 of 75 measurable points
- windbenderohio.com
- google.com/maps/search/Wind+Bender+Heating+Cooling+Plumbing+118+N+West
- elicense4.com.ohio.gov/Lookup/GenerateRoster.aspx
- windbenderohio.com/
- windbenderohio.com/water-heaters/
Checked Oct 6, 2026.
- #9
Allegiant Plumbing
4.8 from 130 Google reviews · Based in Columbus
What stands out
- 4.8 Google rating from 130 reviews
Worth knowing
- No warranty terms found on its website
- License
- Ohio OCILB Plumbing Contractor PL.47909, confirmed on the public lookup
- Founded
- 2015
- Insurance on file
- Ask for a certificate
- Warranty
- None found in writing
Visit website of Allegiant PlumbingThis button does not contact Allegiant Plumbing. We match you with one licensed plumber and tell you who before sharing anything.
Full score breakdown and sources
Strongest factors: a Google rating of 4.8 from 130 reviews and a stated founding year of 2015.
- Google Google rating 4.8 from 130 reviews (as of Oct 6, 2026) Source
- Founded BBB profile lists the business as started in 2015 Source
- License Ohio OCILB Plumbing Contractor PL.47909, confirmed on the public lookup Source
- Insurance No public insurance record checked; ask for a certificate.
- Coverage Data coverage: 75 of 75 measurable points
- allegiantplumbing.com/
- google.com/maps/search/Allegiant+Plumbing+McKinley+Ave+Columbus+OH
- elicense4.com.ohio.gov/Lookup/LicenseLookup.aspx
- bbb.org/us/oh/columbus/profile/plumber/allegiant-plumbing-0302-7014915
Checked Oct 6, 2026.
- #10
Shorty's Plumbing LLC
4.9 from 114 Google reviews · Based in Columbus
What stands out
- 4.9 Google rating from 114 reviews
- Lists warranty or guarantee terms on its website
Worth knowing
- 1 years in business
- License
- Ohio OCILB Plumbing Contractor PL.50488, confirmed on the public lookup
- Founded
- 2025
- Insurance on file
- Ask for a certificate
- Warranty
- 1-year workmanship warranty on every repair and installation
Visit website of Shorty's Plumbing LLCThis button does not contact Shorty's Plumbing LLC. We match you with one licensed plumber and tell you who before sharing anything.
Full score breakdown and sources
Strongest factors: a Google rating of 4.9 from 114 reviews and 3 of 3 core jobs listed.
- Google Google rating 4.9 from 114 reviews (as of Oct 6, 2026) Source
- Founded Operating since 2025 Source
- License Ohio OCILB Plumbing Contractor PL.50488, confirmed on the public lookup Source
- Insurance No public insurance record checked; ask for a certificate.
- Warranty 1-year workmanship warranty on every repair and installation
- Coverage Data coverage: 75 of 75 measurable points
- shortysplumbingllc.com/
- google.com/maps/search/Shorty's+Plumbing+1425+E+Weber+Rd+Columbus+OH
- elicense4.com.ohio.gov/Lookup/LicenseLookup.aspx
- bbb.org/us/oh/columbus/profile/residential-plumber/shortys-plumbing-ll
- shortysplumbingllc.com/water-heater-columbus
Checked Oct 6, 2026.
Need a water heater plumber in Columbus?
Tell us about the job in three short steps. We tell you which licensed plumber we would match you with before we share anything. Free, no obligation.
How the score works
Points per factor, out of the 75 we can measure in Columbus, scaled to 100.
- 30Rating
- 15Reviews
- 20Years
- 6Services
- 4Warranty
The full method
Google rating is blended toward 4.3 stars with 25 imaginary reviews (30 points), then Google review count (15), years in business (20), the water heater services it lists (6) and a published written warranty (4). A company with no Google listing gets 0 for both Google factors. A company is listed only if at least 90% of those points come from records we checked, it scores at least 60, and any plumbing license its state requires is confirmed on the public lookup. A factor we could not check after two tries is estimated at the 25th percentile for Columbus and marked as an estimate. BBB grades are not used. Google ratings were collected from Google search results on the date shown and will be re-checked.
Quote requests go to one company that pays Strive LeadGen per request, and only if this ranking already places it in the top 5 here. No company pays us for Columbus requests yet. We show an insurance record only where a public one exists; otherwise ask the company for a certificate.
Full ranking method · Listed wrong? Tell us.
Before you hire in Columbus
From city, county and utility sources, checked Oct 14, 2026
- Water utilityColumbus Water & Power (formerly Columbus Department of Public Utilities, Division of Water)Source
- Water hardnessHardness (ppm) 2025: Dublin Road 125 (122-132), Hap Cremean 98 (85-118), Parsons Avenue 123 (122-127); (gpg) 7.3 / 5.7 / 7.2Source
- Water heater permitRequired. Who may pull it: Licensed/registered contractor (plumbing work requires an OCILB-licensed plumbing contractor registered with the City; Columbus also licenses journeyperson plumbers); Issued by City of Columbus Building and Zoning Services (BZS), 111 N Front St, 614-645-7433Source
Columbus guides
Read before you hire
- How much does it cost to replace a water heater in 2026?
- How long does a water heater last? Lifespan by type
- Why is my water heater popping or rumbling?
- What does an anode rod do, and when should it be replaced?
- How much does a tankless water heater cost installed?
- Is there still a federal tax credit for heat pump water heaters?
Other Ohio cities
Water Heater Facts is an information and referral service run by Strive LeadGen LLC. Contractors may pay us when we connect a homeowner with one. Local facts come from city, county and utility sources linked above; rules change, so confirm with the city before you start. Google ratings were collected from Google search results on the date shown and will be re-checked. Ratings and review counts change daily. Company names and logos are trademarks of their owners, shown only to identify each company. No company endorses this list.